📖 Why Google+ Failed and When Google Shut It Down
← Back

Why Google+ Failed and When Google Shut It Down

Google+ is gone. Google closed the consumer version on April 2, 2019 after two data leaks, and retired the last workplace version, Google Currents, on July 5, 2023. It failed because Google built it to solve Google's problem with Facebook rather than a problem its users had, and by 2018 Google's own engineering leadership reported that 90 percent of Google+ sessions lasted under five seconds.

Why Google+ Failed and When Google Shut It Down

What was Google+ supposed to do for Google?

Google+ opened on June 28, 2011 as an invitation-only field trial, and it was not really built for the people signing up. It was built for Google. Facebook was pulling attention and data into a space Google's crawlers could not reach, and Google's advertising business depended on people moving around the open web instead.

The project ran under the internal codename Emerald Sea and was led by Vic Gundotra, a former Microsoft executive who reported to Larry Page. Social was made the company's top priority that year, and teams across search, Gmail, YouTube and Android were pushed to wire Google+ into whatever they were already building.

It was not the first attempt. Google Buzz, bolted onto Gmail in February 2010, built public contact lists out of people's email and drew a Federal Trade Commission complaint within weeks. Google Wave, launched in 2009, was shut down in 2012 because almost nobody could work out what it was for. Google+ was the third try, and this time the whole company was told to care.

Why did Circles never catch on?

Circles was the feature every review led with in 2011. You dragged contacts into groups called family, work or anything else, then chose which group saw each post. Facebook had nothing that clean at the time, and the problem was real: most people do not want a manager reading what they tell their college friends.

The trouble was the setup cost. Circles asked for sorting work before the first post, then asked again every time someone new showed up. A social network has to be useful in the ten seconds between opening it and getting bored, and Circles spent those ten seconds on filing.

There was a deeper problem. Real social graphs overlap. One person can be a coworker, a neighbor and a friend at the same time, and a system that wants a single label per group does not describe that. Facebook later shipped its own list tools and watched them go mostly unused for the same reason. People want to post something and be done, not maintain a database of their relationships.

How empty was Google+ really?

Empty enough that Google eventually published the number itself. Announcing the shutdown in October 2018, Google vice president of engineering Ben Smith wrote that "90 percent of Google+ user sessions are less than five seconds." Nine visits in ten ended before the page had a chance to be interesting.

The gap between accounts and activity is the whole story. Registrations were easy for Google to grow, because signing up for Gmail signed you up for Google+ as well. Attention was the part it could not manufacture. People opened the stream, found posts from technology journalists and Google employees, did not find their sister or their neighbors, and closed the tab.

Social networks run on a loop: your people are there, so you go, so you post, so your people keep going. Google+ never closed that loop. The collapse of MySpace a few years earlier showed how fast a network empties once the loop breaks, and the story of Friendster showed the same thing a decade before that. Google+ never got the loop started at all.

Why did forcing Google+ on YouTube backfire?

In November 2013, Google made a Google+ account a requirement for commenting on YouTube. The stated goal was better comments. The effect was a revolt by the people who made YouTube worth watching.

The sharpest response came from Jawed Karim, who co-founded YouTube and uploaded the site's first video in 2005. He changed that video's description to read: "I can't comment here anymore, since i don't want a Google+ account." The Register reported the protest in November 2013, and it spread through creators and commenters who had never asked for a social network.

Google backed off in stages. The real-name rule, which had pushed away people posting under pseudonyms, was dropped in July 2014. The YouTube requirement went in July 2015, along with the Google+ profile requirement on other Google products. By then the damage was structural. Google had spent four years teaching hundreds of millions of people that Google+ was something done to them, and that is a hard lesson to unteach.

Is Google+ still around in 2026?

No. Google+ shut down for consumers on April 2, 2019, and nothing has replaced it under that name. The last piece of it, the workplace version called Google Currents, was retired on July 5, 2023, and Google deleted the remaining Currents data that August. There is no Google+ account to sign into in 2026 and no way to create one.

Two security failures set the ending date. In March 2018 Google found a bug in the Google+ People API that had exposed profile data for up to 500,000 accounts, and chose not to say so publicly at the time. When the story reached the press in October 2018, Google announced the bug and the shutdown together, citing "low usage and engagement." In December 2018 a second bug surfaced, this one exposing data from 52.5 million accounts during about six days in November. NPR reported that Google then moved the shutdown up by four months, from August 2019 to April 2019.

Public posts were not all lost. Volunteers from Archive Team copied public Google+ posts and profiles to the Internet Archive before the shutdown, and anyone who ran Google Takeout before April 2019 kept a copy of their own.

What survived Google+?

More than the name suggests. Hangouts, the video calling tool built inside Google+, was pulled out as its own product and eventually became Google Meet and Google Chat. Google+ Photos was split off in May 2015 as Google Photos, which outlived the network it was born in and is now one of Google's most used consumer products.

Google Currents, the workplace version, ran until July 5, 2023, when Google folded its function into Spaces in Google Chat. That is where the Google+ idea actually landed: not a public square built to fight Facebook, but group conversations inside a company's own account.

The pattern is familiar to anyone who watched Google Reader disappear in 2013. Google ships, Google measures, and Google closes what does not clear the bar. At roughly $585 million by the Forbes estimate of 2011, made up of about $125 million in compensation and $460 million in related acquisitions, Google+ is the most expensive example. It is not an unusual one.

Frequently Asked Questions

When did Google+ shut down?

Google+ shut down for consumers on April 2, 2019, almost eight years after it launched on June 28, 2011. Its developer APIs were switched off on March 7, 2019. The workplace version, renamed Google Currents, kept running until July 5, 2023, which is when Google+ ended for everyone.

Why did Google shut down Google+?

Google announced the end of Google+ in October 2018 and gave two reasons: almost nobody used it, and a bug in its API had exposed profile data for up to 500,000 accounts. Google's own announcement cited "low usage and engagement" and the "challenges involved in maintaining a successful product that meets consumers' expectations." A second bug disclosed in December 2018, affecting 52.5 million accounts, moved the shutdown up to April 2019.

Does Google have a social network in 2026?

Google runs no public social network in 2026. Google+ closed in April 2019 and Google Currents closed in July 2023, leaving Spaces in Google Chat for workplace group conversations and YouTube, which carries comments and subscriptions without being sold as a social network. Google has not launched another Facebook competitor since Google+.

Sources

404 Memory Found
📝 Blog Posts
â„šī¸ About
đŸ“Ļ Archives
âœī¸ Guestbook
🧩 Memory Defrag
🔍 Nostalgia Scanner
✨ Cursor Trail: OFF
📁 Don't Click Here
00:00